Beware of dodgy insurance

"A huge victory for consumers" is how Peter Vicary-Smith, head of Which?, hailed the latest payment protection insurance (PPI) proposals from the Competition Commission. No wonder. As Thisismoney.co.uk notes, the "charge sheet against PPI" (which is meant to insure you against being unable to repay a loan or credit-card balance if you fall ill or lose your job) is long. Complaints about Britain's 13 million policies include that it's "overpriced, sold to people who can never claim on it, sold with no cancellation clause, and often ineffective". It's also often "forced on customers by pushy sales staff".

June that PPI providers overcharge customers by £1.4bn a year, against annual sales of £5.5bn. So what's changing? The Competition Commission stopped short of banning PPI altogether. But it is banning "single premium policies", where the premium is paid up front and often added to the original loan as a lump sum. Providers will also be stopped from pushing customers to take PPI immediately. They will have to wait 14 days and tailor any quote to ensure the policy is suitable.

Fine, say the banks – but loan rates will rise because the income from PPI sales often subsidises interest charges. And the changes come just as people need cover going into a recession. This is "nonsense", as The Independent's Julian Knight puts it. There's "never a good time to be mis-sold a policy". The extra transparency should stop millions from buying cover they either don't need, or that doesn't do what they expect. If you think you may have been sold an unsuitable PPI plan – some campaigners reckon there's a problem with up to half of them – you can complain to...finanacial.